Your first blog post begins by explaining why it deserves no particular importance for being the first.
You were not especially interested in beginnings, apparently. You wrote that your first relationship, your first phone, and the other experiences people tend to preserve with special affection had never meant more to you merely because they came before everything else. You preferred the present, and you saw little reason to return to something that had already happened when there was still a life ahead.
You compared time to a highway. The people travelling beside us belonged, for a while, to our lives, but those who took another road could no longer be expected to accompany us. You found it unreasonable to abandon your own journey in pursuit of someone who had chosen a different direction. You even compared returning to an old relationship to driving back along a road in search of the first petrol station at which you had stopped, despite having passed many others since.
Eventually, you suggested that people ought to remove their rearview mirrors.
I found this rather amusing.
Thirteen years later, I have been reading the things you wrote, returning to a past you considered largely unworthy of revisiting, and trying to understand the person who could speak about it with such apparent confidence.
I wonder what you would make of that.
I remember very little about the circumstances in which you wrote those essays. I cannot recall whether a particular friendship had ended, whether someone had disappointed you, or whether you had simply been watching the people around you and trying to understand why they behaved as they did. You left few traces of the questions that preceded your conclusions.
But I recognize the desire to find an explanation.
In another essay, you tried to understand what it meant to value another person. You argued that affection created expectations, that making someone feel important established responsibilities, and that people often became resentful when the attention they had grown accustomed to receiving began to diminish.
You compared the desire to feel valued to an addiction, then followed the comparison through friendships, work, approval, and even humiliation. You seemed to believe that if you could identify what each person received from a relationship, you could explain why they remained in it, what they expected from it, and why its failure might hurt them.
Your conclusions were not always kind, and I would challenge many of them now. You sometimes treated expectations as though their existence made them justified, and you moved too readily from observing that people seek recognition to deciding why particular people behave as they do.
Yet I do not think the impulse behind the writing was entirely misguided.
You had noticed that being valued matters to people, and that the withdrawal of another person’s attention can cause a pain disproportionate to the outward event. You had noticed that affection is not experienced in isolation, that what one person gives may change what another comes to expect, and that the failure of those expectations can alter the relationship itself.
There was something worth understanding there.
I suspect you were trying to find a form in which these observations could become manageable. Perhaps the form mattered as much as the conclusions. If relationships followed certain conditions, their failures might be explained. If the past no longer deserved attention, the people who belonged to it might lose some of their power to hurt you.
I cannot be certain that this is how you understood what you were doing. You may have believed every word without any awareness of the protection those beliefs could provide. Perhaps you were simply trying out explanations, as people do when they first discover how satisfying it can be to arrange a confusing world into something that appears coherent.
But I remember enough of our later life to suspect that protection was part of it.
And I recognize something else.
You were willing to write.
You had an idea, followed it through several examples, arrived at a conclusion, and allowed the conclusion to stand. You did not seem particularly troubled by the possibility that another person might disagree, that an exception might undermine your argument, or that you yourself might understand the subject differently a few years later.
I cannot imagine writing those essays in quite the same way today.
This is a strange thing to admit, because almost everything I have done since then ought to have made expression easier.
I studied languages and literature. I learned to recognize structures beneath sentences, distinctions between meanings that had once seemed interchangeable, and the countless ways an intention may change between the person who expresses it and the person who receives it. I learned other languages, wrote poems and stories, and found ways to articulate experiences for which I had previously possessed little more than an indistinct impression.
I can say things now that you would not have known how to say. I can also recognize more clearly when I have failed to say what I intended.
Perhaps that is where some of the difficulty begins.
I have become increasingly aware of what language permits, what it conceals, and how easily a statement can imply something its author did not mean. I can hear possible objections before I have finished forming an argument. I recognize the qualifications that would make a sentence more accurate, the examples that might contradict it, and the experiences of other people that my account has not yet considered.
I value this awareness. I would not willingly return to a way of thinking in which such distinctions were invisible.
Yet I have sometimes allowed the effort to account for them to become a condition of speaking at all.
I revise thoughts before they have finished arriving. I hesitate to express a conviction until I have considered the objections it might invite. Sometimes I can recognize something as meaningful to my experience without immediately knowing how to explain it, and the work of making that recognition defensible becomes greater than my willingness to share it.
I have not lost the ability to find words. I have become reluctant to let them leave me before I know what they might become in someone else’s understanding.
And the habit reaches beyond writing.
I have always been curious about how things work. When something interests me, I want to know what moves beneath its visible surface, which conditions made it possible, and how the smallest change might produce an entirely different result. This curiosity has accompanied me through almost every subject I have tried to learn.
It also accompanies me into my relationships with people.
I want to understand what others notice, what they value, what they find beautiful or intolerable, and how their experiences have shaped the meanings they attach to things. I am interested in the differences between our ways of seeing, especially when those differences reveal something neither of us would have discovered alone.
For a long time, I have regarded understanding as one of the ways I care for others. There is something meaningful in attending to another person closely enough to recognize that their actions may have meanings beyond those immediately apparent to us, and in allowing an unfamiliar experience to remain unfamiliar rather than forcing it into the nearest available explanation.
I still believe that.
But I have also begun to recognize how easily the wish to understand can become an attempt to make uncertainty manageable.
Sometimes I want an explanation because I am curious. Sometimes I want one because I am hurt, and I hope that understanding the cause will prevent the experience from happening again.
Not long ago, I sent someone a small, playful message, referring to something we had talked about before. I thought it might become the beginning of a conversation. It was acknowledged warmly, but nothing more followed.
There was nothing particularly unusual about that. I knew the other person might be busy, might not feel conversational, or might simply have enjoyed the message without wanting to continue. I had considered all these possibilities before sending it. I had even told myself that any of them would be perfectly acceptable.
And yet I was disappointed.
I had hoped for a little conversation. Perhaps a laugh, another joke, a song sent without explanation. Something ordinary that might have given us a reason to know each other a little better.
Instead, I found myself wondering whether I had chosen the wrong moment, whether I had mistaken an earlier kindness for greater curiosity, or whether something about my message had made the exchange easier to acknowledge than to continue.
I understood how little any of these explanations could establish.
Still, I examined them.
I can spend an extraordinary amount of time reconsidering the circumstances of a conversation I only imagined having.
And I think the effort reveals something about the way I have come to experience other people’s interest.
I am often trying to understand not merely what happened, but what I could have done to make something else happen instead.
There are times when such reflection reveals something useful. I have misunderstood people before. I have expressed myself poorly, overlooked another person’s circumstances, or failed to recognize that an invitation was not being offered. I do not want to become incapable of learning from those experiences.
But I have noticed how often I continue searching after the evidence has ceased to support any particular conclusion.
I can know that several explanations are possible, that none is established, and that the other person’s reasons may remain inaccessible to me. Yet I find myself returning to the same questions, as though the persistence of uncertainty were evidence that I had not considered them carefully enough.
Somewhere in this process, I begin treating an interaction that did not develop as though it were an outcome for which I must have been responsible.
And I think this has shaped much more of my life than the occasional conversation.
There have been many occasions when I was excited about something and wanted to share it.
I remember the pleasure of discovering a connection I had not expected, of finally understanding why something behaved as it did, or of making something that had existed only as an uncertain idea a few hours earlier. I would become absorbed in the explanation, moving quickly between details because each one seemed necessary to communicate what had made the discovery so satisfying.
I wanted another person to see what I had seen.
And sometimes the attempt ended in a way that changed the feeling itself.
An impatient response, a dismissive remark, or the suggestion that I was making too much of something could leave me embarrassed by an enthusiasm I had been entirely comfortable experiencing alone.
I would stop explaining. I would make some small joke about having become carried away, or apologize for occupying too much of the conversation.
Then I would return to whatever had interested me, only to find that the happiness had become difficult to recover.
The subject was unchanged. The discovery remained a discovery. Whatever I had made or understood was no less meaningful than it had been before. But something had entered the experience that was not there when I was alone.
I had become conscious of how my happiness appeared to someone else.
I do not think every such moment was an act of unkindness. People have limits upon their attention. They become tired, distracted, or uninterested in subjects that happen to fascinate us. I have undoubtedly done the same to others, sometimes without recognizing it.
There is no reason another person should be required to share every enthusiasm I experience.
But understanding the legitimacy of their limits did not always protect me from the feeling that I had been foolish to express myself. I could recognize that someone was tired and still wonder whether they were tired of me. I could accept that a subject did not interest them and still feel ashamed of how much it interested me.
And because those experiences stayed with me, I gradually became more attentive to the possibility of repeating them.
I learned to recognize the moment when an explanation might be growing too long. I became quicker to shorten it, to dismiss a detail as unimportant, or to stop before anyone had asked me to stop.
Sometimes this was ordinary consideration for another person’s attention. Sometimes I suspect I was withdrawing before there had been any need. It is difficult to determine where one became the other, because the behavior looked much the same from the outside.
I was simply being careful.
And over time, carefulness became so familiar that I stopped recognizing how much of myself it sometimes required me to withhold.
I think this is connected to the way I have learned to make jokes about myself.
I enjoy humor. I like absurdity, unexpected associations, and the pleasure of treating something entirely ridiculous with a seriousness it does not deserve. I have no wish to explain every joke through some hidden insecurity, or to regard laughter as evidence that I am avoiding a more authentic feeling.
But I have noticed that self-deprecation sometimes appears at a very particular moment.
I show something I have made and immediately mention its shortcomings. I describe an interest, then make light of the time or attention I have devoted to it. I express pride in something and almost immediately find a way to diminish the expression.
I do not necessarily believe the criticism. Sometimes I know perfectly well that what I have made is good, or that the enthusiasm I feel is justified.
Yet the joke makes the exposure easier.
It establishes that I am aware of how ridiculous I might appear. It allows me to reveal something without seeming to demand that anyone take it seriously. And if another person responds with indifference, I can pretend that indifference was always an acceptable conclusion to the joke.
I was only being silly.
Except that sometimes I was also hoping they would notice.
I have been trying to understand what happens when this habit enters the way I approach new people.
I do not meet many people with whom I immediately feel a wish to become better acquainted. I can enjoy someone’s company without particularly wanting to know them beyond the circumstances in which we meet. But occasionally I encounter someone whose way of thinking, humor, interests, or expression makes me curious.
I want to know more about them. I want to hear their opinions, discover what they love, and understand the things that occupy their attention when nobody is asking them to explain themselves.
And almost without noticing, I begin wondering what I might show them in return.
Perhaps they would enjoy something I have written. Perhaps we could talk about music, or art, or some strange subject I have been exploring. Perhaps a joke would lead to another joke, and eventually to a conversation neither of us had intended to have.
These interests are genuine. I have never needed another person’s approval to become fascinated by something, and I do not believe that my curiosity is merely an instrument for attracting attention.
Yet the pleasure of sharing can become entangled with another hope.
I want something I show to make the other person curious about the one who is showing it.
I imagine myself offering one part of my world, then another, hoping that somewhere among them there will be something the other person wants to know more about. And when nothing develops, I begin wondering whether I should have shown something different.
I cannot always tell when an ordinary wish to share has become an attempt to persuade someone that I am worth knowing. The two feelings can inhabit the same gesture. I may genuinely want another person to hear a song, and still find myself wondering afterward whether it gave them any reason to think about me.
There is something exhausting about becoming responsible, even privately, for both sides of an encounter.
I can decide whether to express my interest in another person, what to share, and how honestly to speak. But I cannot decide whether they will become curious about me.
Their interest, if it comes, must belong to them.
And I think this brings me back to something you wrote about affection.
You believed that making someone feel valued created obligations. Once a person had become accustomed to another’s attention, you argued, the withdrawal of that attention could feel like a violation of something they had come to expect.
I understand that argument differently now.
I still believe relationships create responsibilities. What we say and do can establish trust, and trust can be damaged when we disregard the expectations we have helped create.
But the kind of attention I most long for cannot be secured through an obligation.
Someone might feel they ought to answer a message, return a gesture, or show interest because I have shown interest in them. Yet what I want is not merely the response.
I want them to have wished to respond.
I want their curiosity to arise from something they themselves have noticed or remembered, without my having to continually place another reason before them.
And the freedom that makes such curiosity meaningful is the same freedom that allows them not to feel it.
I cannot preserve one while removing the other.
I find that difficult to live with, especially because the opportunities for meaningful connection have often felt so rare.
When I encounter someone whose company interests me, I can begin imagining the relationship long before anything resembling that relationship has formed.
I imagine conversations, disagreements, shared discoveries, ordinary afternoons. I imagine learning what they care about and finding that they are curious about some part of my life in return.
There is no particular deception in these imaginings. I know they are possibilities, not memories. I know the person I am imagining with is not yet the person I would come to know.
But the experience of imagining belonging can be powerful enough that a small disappointment in the actual interaction begins to feel like the loss of something much larger.
I am not merely disappointed that a conversation did not continue. I am disappointed that the life I briefly imagined through it has become less likely, or perhaps was never available in the first place.
I know that one exchange rarely establishes very much about what another person might want in the future. Yet the disappointment remains, and I suspect that the scarcity of such encounters has made each one carry more hope than the circumstances can reasonably sustain.
I have also been considering why certain kinds of people seem to awaken this hope more readily than others.
I am often drawn to artists, writers, and people who appear comfortable expressing themselves in ways that do not fit easily into ordinary expectations.
Sometimes I am interested in what they make. Sometimes what moves me is less the work itself than the apparent freedom with which they allow it to exist.
They share unfinished things. They speak openly about what they love or dislike. They become excited about subjects that may mean very little to anyone outside their own interests. They are sometimes awkward, excessive, uncertain, or difficult to understand, and they seem willing to allow those qualities to remain visible.
At least, that is what I perceive.
I know how incomplete such an impression must be. Public expression reveals only part of a person, and someone who appears unafraid of being seen may have their own elaborate ways of protecting themselves from judgment.
Still, I recognize something in the freedom I imagine them possessing.
And I think I have sometimes confused my attraction to a person with my longing to inhabit the kind of life I associate with them.
I do not necessarily want to become like that person. I want to belong to a world in which I might be able to live with a similar openness.
I want to have friends with whom enthusiasm is ordinary, where becoming absorbed in an idea does not immediately require an apology, and where unfamiliar interests are approached with curiosity rather than suspicion.
I want to make things with people, to argue about things we have made, and to discover that another person has understood something differently and spend an evening trying to explain why.
I want people to disagree with me, sometimes intensely, without every disagreement becoming a question of whether the relationship can survive it. And I want to be allowed to disagree with them.
I do not imagine a life in which everyone is endlessly patient or accommodating. I would find that as difficult to inhabit as one in which no one had any patience at all.
What I imagine is a life in which people have become familiar enough with one another that their imperfections are no longer treated as unexpected revelations. They can become tired, annoyed, distracted, or mistaken without immediately ceasing to belong.
And perhaps what I miss most is that familiarity.
The ordinary accumulation of shared experience through which another person ceases to be someone I must continually introduce myself to.
I want to become part of someone’s life gradually enough that they discover things about me without my having to decide which of those things should be presented first. And I want to discover them in the same way.
I cannot obtain such a relationship merely by recognizing its possibility in someone I admire. That recognition tells me something about the life I want, but it does not establish that the other person wants to share it with me.
I have sometimes imagined people as possible companions in a world I long to inhabit before I have given myself much opportunity to discover who they actually are.
And I do not want to turn them into representations of the acceptance I have been missing.
Their lives are not waiting for me to enter them. They have their own histories, attachments, frustrations, and hopes, many of which may have nothing to do with mine.
If I want to know them, I have to allow them to remain different from what I imagine.
Even when the difference disappoints me.
I wrote a screenplay recently.
It concerns a man who has become so afraid of misunderstanding people that he builds increasingly elaborate ways to interpret and manage his relationships. What begins as an attempt to reduce uncertainty gradually becomes a system for arranging encounters, anticipating responses, and preventing conversations from developing in directions he cannot comfortably predict.
He believes he is protecting the relationships that matter to him.
But the assistance gradually changes what he is willing to reveal of himself. His disagreements become agreeable questions. His doubts are replaced by carefully constructed reassurance. He becomes so occupied with avoiding the possibility of conflict that the people around him begin to lose access to what he actually thinks.
I thought I was writing about the dangers of attempting to manage relationships through understanding.
I still think that is part of what I wrote.
But there is a scene in the screenplay that I have been returning to, and I suspect it contains a wish I had not known how to express directly.
The man is working on a simulation of a black hole. He has been struggling with the rendering, and something about the behavior of the light has begun to make sense. He wants to show his girlfriend what he has discovered, and he keeps asking her to look at differences between images that, to her tired eyes, appear almost identical.
She has come home after a long day.
She does not understand the mathematics. She cannot see why the change matters so much, and after a while she tells him that she has a headache and cannot look at screens anymore.
He closes the work immediately.
He believes he has annoyed her. He feels embarrassed by how eagerly he had tried to share something she did not seem interested in understanding.
Later that night, after he has fallen asleep, she returns to the computer.
She moves the camera around the simulated black hole. The rendering is still broken, and she still has no idea what she is looking at.
But she remembers his face while he was explaining it.
She remembers how alive he looked.
And she loves that about him.
I have been thinking about why I wrote this.
The scene does not depend upon the woman discovering an interest in the mathematics. She has not suddenly learned to appreciate the technical achievement, nor has she acquired a new understanding of the subject.
What remains with her is the memory of his happiness.
Something mattered deeply to him, and because he mattered to her, she found herself curious about it after he was no longer there to explain.
I think the fact that he is absent matters.
He cannot improve the presentation, make another joke, or offer a more accessible explanation. He cannot observe her reaction and adjust himself to it.
He does not even know that she has returned.
Her curiosity is entirely her own.
I think I wanted to imagine what it would feel like to be remembered in that way.
To have someone see that I am happy, and to find that happiness meaningful even when they do not understand or share its cause.
I do not need someone to admire every project I undertake. I do not want another person to feel obliged to become interested in everything that occupies my attention.
But I would like them to find some pleasure in knowing that something has made me happy. And I would like to offer them the same attention.
There is something I find deeply moving about encountering another person’s enthusiasm, even when the subject itself is unfamiliar to me. I like listening to people describe things they love. I like the sudden changes in their expressions, the details they cannot resist including, the way an ordinary subject becomes extraordinary through the attention they have given it.
I want to know what makes people feel alive.
I think I have wanted someone to be curious about that part of me, too.
There is another part of the scene I now find equally important.
The woman explains that she had been tired that evening, and that he had been happy. Both things were allowed to be true.
I think I needed to write that distinction.
I have often understood another person’s exhaustion as a limit upon their willingness to listen, while feeling it as a limit upon their willingness to know me.
But those are not the same thing.
Someone can care about me and still need an evening in which they are not asked to share my interests. Their affection does not make their patience infinite, and my desire to be understood does not remove my responsibility to notice their limits.
What I want is not an arrangement in which neither person is ever disappointed. I want enough trust that a moment of disappointment does not immediately threaten the connection itself.
Enough familiarity that an awkward conversation can remain an awkward conversation, rather than becoming evidence that one of us has ceased to be welcome.
In the final scene of the screenplay, the characters are arguing about a novel.
They disagree about its meaning. One interrupts the other. They return to earlier passages, challenge interpretations, and become increasingly involved in an argument neither seems particularly eager to conclude.
They are not trying to maintain a pleasant atmosphere at the expense of what they think. They are participating in something together.
And the screenplay ends with them still talking.
I think that may be as important to me as the earlier scene.
The woman who returns to the computer is not merely someone who admires the man from a distance. She has her own opinions, her own frustrations, and reasons to disagree with him. At other points in the story, she is angry with him, and her anger is justified. Her willingness to understand him does not require her to accept everything he does.
I did not want to imagine someone who would make every difficulty disappear. I wanted to imagine a relationship in which the difficulties could be encountered without either person having to vanish behind a more agreeable version of themselves.
For some time, I have treated this scene as an expression of what I hope to receive from another person.
But I think there is something else in it that I had not recognized until I returned to your writing.
I went back to your old blog because something about the person who wrote it had begun to matter to me again.
I did not return because I agreed with the essays. I was not especially impressed by the arguments, and I could see their limitations more readily than I could when I first encountered them. Some passages made me smile; others made me uncomfortable. There were conclusions I wanted to challenge, and questions I wished you had considered before arriving at them.
Yet I continued reading.
I wanted to understand what had occupied your attention, what you had been trying to explain, and why those questions had mattered enough for you to write about them.
I wanted to know the person behind the words, even when the words themselves were mistaken.
And I did not require you to be right before finding something worth caring about.
I recognize the resemblance to the scene I wrote, although I do not think the two experiences are quite the same.
The woman returns to the computer because she remembers someone she loves. I have returned to these pages because I am trying to understand someone I once was, and whose life I have continued living without always recognizing how much of him remains.
There is no one here to explain the essays to me.
You cannot clarify an argument, defend an assumption, or tell me that I have misunderstood what you meant. You left the writing as it was, and I have encountered it as someone you could not have anticipated.
But I am interested in you.
I find that difficult to say without immediately wanting to qualify it, to explain that I do not admire all your convictions, that I understand how incomplete your arguments were, and that I have no desire to recover the person you were at the expense of the person I have become.
All of those things are true.
Yet perhaps I do not need to establish them before allowing the simpler feeling to exist.
I am glad I found you.
And I think this has begun to change what I understand myself to be doing with this letter.
When I first returned to your writing, I was struck by a freedom I thought I had lost. You seemed capable of saying things without the elaborate hesitation that has become so familiar to me. I wanted to know where that confidence had gone, what had happened in the years between us, and whether I could recover some part of it.
I was looking at you as though you possessed something I needed.
And perhaps, without realizing it, I had begun treating the person I am now as the consequence of everything that had gone wrong along the way.
The boy who could speak freely had become the person who hesitated. The boy who expressed himself without apparent embarrassment had become the person who sometimes concealed his enthusiasm behind a joke. The boy who seemed untroubled by the past had become someone who remembered small disappointments long after they had ceased to matter to anyone else.
I began arranging these differences into an account of loss.
There is truth in that account. I have become more guarded in ways that sometimes make my life smaller than I would like. I have learned habits of anticipation and withdrawal that no longer serve me as well as they once may have. And I do miss the ease with which I imagine you approached expression.
But I have been overlooking something.
You were not simply a freer version of me.
You were also trying to understand things that had already begun to hurt, perhaps, and constructing explanations that might make those experiences easier to endure. You had your own ways of avoiding uncertainty, your own assumptions about what other people owed you, and your own difficulties with allowing the world to remain different from what you believed it should be.
I do not know how much of this you recognized at the time.
Perhaps you were genuinely less afraid of being wrong. Perhaps you were merely less aware of the ways in which you could be wrong. Perhaps there were occasions when you were just as hesitant as I am now, and they happened to leave no trace in the writing.
I cannot recover enough of your life to settle those questions.
And I no longer think I need to.
I have been comparing us as though one of us must represent a more authentic way of being. But the things I recognize in you have not disappeared. The curiosity, the desire to understand, the pleasure of following an idea through its consequences, and even the tendency to construct explanations when uncertainty becomes difficult are all still here.
They have changed with experience. Some have become more careful. Others have become more elaborate. A few have acquired expressions that neither of us would have recognized thirteen years ago.
And perhaps some of the things I now find difficult are not evidence that I have become less myself.
They are part of what has happened to me while I have continued being myself.
I do not mean that every habit deserves to be preserved, or that the pain which contributed to it must be regarded as necessary for the person I have become. I would not wish those experiences upon you merely because I can now recognize some of their consequences.
There are things I would like to change.
I would like to be less afraid of expressing affection, less inclined to interpret another person’s silence as a judgment upon me, and less likely to diminish something I love before allowing anyone else to see it.
I would like to become more comfortable with the possibility that someone may not find me interesting, and that their lack of interest need not alter what I think of myself.
But I have begun to wonder why I so often place these changes between myself and the possibility of feeling comfortable with who I am.
It is as though I have been waiting to become someone who no longer hesitates, who no longer worries about being misunderstood, who can express himself without the old embarrassment, before I will allow myself to believe that there is nothing inherently regrettable about the person who does those things.
I can acknowledge another person’s awkwardness without regarding it as a defect in their character. I can find their enthusiasm endearing even when I do not share it. I can understand that their fears and habits have histories, that some of their responses may be disproportionate to the present moment, and that none of this necessarily diminishes my wish to know them.
I rarely require someone to become a more polished version of themselves before finding them worth knowing.
But I have been much less willing to extend the same consideration to myself.
I have treated my hesitations as things to be explained, my disappointments as failures of interpretation, and my desire for connection as something that must be carefully managed lest it become excessive.
Even when I have understood why these feelings arise, I have often regarded their continued presence as evidence that the understanding has not yet done its work.
Perhaps I have been asking understanding to accomplish something it cannot accomplish alone.
It can help me recognize the circumstances in which a habit developed. It can reveal where an old response has ceased to fit the present, and where my interpretations have begun to exceed what I actually know.
It can make change possible.
But it cannot make the person who needs that change unworthy of acceptance until the change has occurred.
I think I have been confusing those two things.
And I suspect that some of the exhaustion I have felt comes from living as though every new understanding of myself creates another obligation to become different.
I discover why I hesitate, and begin trying not to hesitate. I recognize that I sometimes perform for other people’s interest, and begin worrying whether my next expression of enthusiasm is sufficiently spontaneous. I notice that I use humor to protect myself, and become uncertain whether even my jokes are honest.
I become so concerned with allowing myself to be natural that I find myself monitoring whether I am behaving naturally enough.
There is something almost comical about the persistence of the pattern.
I cannot seem to approach the problem without immediately trying to build another way of managing it.
And perhaps that, too, is something I ought to recognize without turning it into an accusation.
The wish to understand has accompanied me for as long as I can remember. It has given me an extraordinary amount of pleasure. It has shaped the way I learn, the things I make, the questions I ask, and much of what I value about being alive.
It has also become entangled with fears I do not always know how to separate from it.
I do not think the whole of that curiosity must be corrected because of the ways it sometimes causes me difficulty. Nor do I think the difficulties become less real simply because I can identify something valuable in the impulse that produces them.
Both belong to the person I am.
And I think I am beginning to understand that accepting this does not require me to decide that I must remain exactly as I am.
I can dislike the way I retreat from an interaction without disliking the person who became afraid enough to retreat. I can recognize that I am trying too hard to be interesting without being ashamed of how much I want to be known. I can acknowledge that an imagined friendship has become more important to me than the actual relationship can yet support, and still regard the longing beneath it with some tenderness.
I want companionship. I want shared experiences, conversations that continue because both people wish to continue them, and relationships in which affection does not have to be continually demonstrated to remain believable.
These desires have sometimes made me vulnerable to disappointment. They may continue to do so.
But I do not think the vulnerability makes the desires mistaken.
And I do not think I have to become indifferent to the possibility of being hurt before I can participate in the relationships I hope to have.
There is something I would like to tell you about the years since those essays.
I have made things you could not have imagined making. I have explored subjects that would have seemed impossibly distant from the concerns that occupied you, and discovered that the distance between one interest and another is often much smaller than it first appears.
I have learned to write in other languages. I have written poems, letters, and stories. I have built simulations of things I may never encounter with my own eyes, partly because understanding how they work brings me closer to experiencing them.
I have found that the world contains more things worth knowing than I once believed possible.
And I have become more willing to follow that curiosity wherever it leads.
I think you would enjoy some of what I have made.
You would probably have opinions about it, too.
I would like to hear them.
I would like to show you a few things, explain why they matter to me, and discover whether you could recognize the same pleasure in them that once made you sit down and write about the world.
I suspect I would become carried away with the explanation.
And perhaps, at some point, I would apologize for talking too much.
I wonder what you would make of that.
Perhaps you would laugh. Perhaps you would be impatient. Perhaps you would understand something I have forgotten about how we used to speak before I began considering every possible response.
But I would like to imagine that we could continue the conversation.
That I could disagree with some of what you believed, and you could disagree with what I have become, without either of us needing to establish which version deserved to be here.
There is something comforting about that possibility, even though the conversation cannot happen.
I can only write to you.
And perhaps that is why the form of a letter has become so important to me.
I find it easier to speak when I can imagine someone listening. The presence of another person, even an imagined one, changes the shape of what I am trying to say. It gives the words a destination without necessarily requiring them to arrive.
Sometimes I have thought of this as another form of caution.
I can reveal something in a letter without having to face the immediate uncertainty of another person’s response. I can take my time, return to a thought, and allow contradictions to remain where they might otherwise make a conversation uncomfortable.
But I do not think that is the whole of it.
Writing to someone also allows me to remember that expression is a relation, even when the letter remains unsent. I am not merely arranging observations about myself. I am trying to make something of my experience available to another perspective.
In this case, the perspective belongs to someone who cannot answer.
And yet I find that addressing you has allowed me to say things I had difficulty saying when I was speaking only about myself.
I can acknowledge that you were confused without feeling obliged to condemn you for it. I can recognize the defenses in your writing without treating them as evidence that everything you believed was insincere. I can understand why you might have wanted the past to lose its authority over you, and still disagree with your attempt to dismiss it.
I can care about the person who wrote those things without requiring him to have known better.
I have been wondering why that feels easier.
Perhaps the distance of thirteen years allows me to recognize the circumstances in which you were trying to live. Perhaps it is easier to forgive mistakes once they have become part of a history whose consequences can no longer be changed.
Or perhaps I have simply become accustomed to extending more patience to other people than to myself.
I do not know.
But I notice that the same patience becomes harder to sustain when I turn toward the person writing this letter.
I am willing to understand you as someone who was learning.
I am less willing to acknowledge that I still am.
And I think that is something I would like to change.
Not the fact that I am learning, but the expectation that I should have finished by now.
There is no particular age at which the effort to understand oneself becomes complete. I know this intellectually, just as I know that other people remain capable of changing throughout their lives.
Yet I have often treated my own uncertainty as evidence that I am still waiting to become the person I should already have been.
I have wondered whether the social difficulties that have accompanied me for so long might eventually disappear, whether I will become less awkward, less hesitant, less susceptible to the small disappointments that seem to remain with me longer than they should.
Perhaps some of these things will change.
I hope they do.
But I am beginning to understand that I have been postponing something that need not depend upon their disappearance.
I can acknowledge that this is who I am.
Not because every part of me is fixed, nor because the person I am now is the final form my life will take.
I have changed before, and I expect to change again. The things I believe, the ways I express myself, and the relationships I form will continue to alter what I understand about myself.
But those future changes do not make the present person provisional.
I am already here.
I am the person who becomes excited about things and sometimes struggles to share that excitement. I am the person who wants to understand other people, sometimes so intensely that I become afraid of misunderstanding them. I am the person who enjoys solitude and still longs for companionship, who can feel confident in what he creates and uncertain whether anyone will want to know the person who created it.
I am capable of affection, curiosity, resentment, generosity, embarrassment, and all the ordinary contradictions I have spent so much time trying to explain.
I am not always easy to understand.
There are times when I do not understand myself particularly well.
And I think I have been waiting too long for those difficulties to be resolved before allowing them to belong to me.
I still want to be less guarded. I still want to find people among whom my enthusiasm can become ordinary, where I can be awkward without immediately feeling ashamed, and where a disagreement need not threaten the relationship itself.
But I no longer want to approach those hopes as evidence that the life I am living is somehow awaiting permission to begin.
That does not resolve the loneliness.
It does not guarantee that the people I admire will become curious about me, or that I will find the companionship I have been imagining. There will still be conversations that end before I want them to, people whose interest I cannot understand, and moments when an old embarrassment returns before I can recognize what has happened.
I will probably continue to overthink some of them.
I may still make the self-deprecating joke, withdraw from an encounter I wanted to pursue, or spend an evening wondering whether something I said was a mistake.
I would like to become more capable of noticing those moments without allowing them to determine what I believe about myself afterward.
And when I fail to do that, I would like the failure not to become another reason for embarrassment.
I do not know how easily I will manage it.
But I find that I am less interested now in constructing a method through which I might finally become someone I can accept.
I would rather learn to remain with the person who is already trying.
And this brings me back to you.
I began writing because I thought you might help me recover something I had lost.
You seemed to possess a freedom I could no longer recognize in myself, and I wanted to know whether the years between us had taken it away.
I still think there are things worth recovering.
But I no longer want to make you into a better version of me, someone whose confidence must be restored before I can consider the intervening years worthwhile.
You were trying to understand the world with the knowledge you possessed. I am trying to understand it with the knowledge I have acquired since.
We have both been mistaken. We have both tried to protect ourselves through explanations, and we have both wanted things from other people that no explanation could guarantee.
I have become more careful in some ways, more vulnerable in others, and more capable of recognizing how little I can know about another person’s experience.
I do not think these developments form a simple story of progress or decline.
They are things that have happened in the course of living.
And I am beginning to feel less compelled to arrange them into an argument about which parts of myself I ought to keep.
I can remember what you believed without needing to believe it again. I can regret some of the ways I have learned to protect myself without regretting the person those protections accompanied. I can want a different future without requiring the present to justify itself through the promise of becoming that future.
There is something unfamiliar about allowing those thoughts to remain together.
I am accustomed to trying to establish what follows from an understanding, what responsibility it creates, and which action ought to come next.
But I do not think every recognition has to become an instruction.
Perhaps I can simply be glad to have found these pages.
I have found your old name again, too.
Prougen.
I do not remember how you invented it, what it was meant to signify, or why you chose it. Perhaps there was a story behind it that I have forgotten. Perhaps you simply liked the sound.
I find that I do not particularly need to know.
There are enough things I have tried to explain about myself. It is strangely pleasant to encounter something that belongs to our history without feeling compelled to recover every cause that brought it into existence.
I think I will keep it.
Not because I want to return to being the boy who wrote those essays, but because I would like to remain connected to him without having to agree with everything he believed.
It belonged to you when you knew less than I know now. It belongs to me while there is still so much I do not understand.
And perhaps it is enough that I recognize it as ours.
I have been thinking about the first words you used when introducing yourself.
Merhaba ben Prougen.
You wrote them without knowing what thirteen more years of living would do to the person who spoke them. You could not have known what he would learn, what he would make, or the ways in which he would sometimes become afraid of expressing the very things that made him happy.
You could not have known that he would return to your words and begin questioning why you had written them, or that the questions would eventually turn toward him.
I do not think you would have expected this letter.
I did not expect it either.
I thought I was writing to understand what I had lost. Then I found myself wanting to understand what you had been trying to protect. And somewhere along the way, I began wondering why I have been so reluctant to offer the same understanding to the person I have become.
I cannot say that I have resolved the question.
I still recognize the old habits in myself. I still hesitate, still become embarrassed, still hope for things from other people that I cannot make happen.
But I have written about those things now, and I find that I no longer want to treat them as evidence against myself.
They are part of my life. Not the whole of it, and not necessarily the parts that will remain unchanged.
But mine, nonetheless.
I think I began this letter wanting you to tell me how to become more like you.
I am less certain now that either of us needs the other to become anything.
There are things I would like to show you. Things I have written, things I have made, and questions that have occupied me for longer than either of us might have considered reasonable. I would like to hear what you think of them, even if we disagree.
And there are things I would like to ask you, although I know I will never receive an answer.
I suppose I will have to live with that.
I have learned enough about uncertainty to know that it does not always become easier merely because one understands why it cannot be resolved.
But I am glad you wrote.
I am glad you left something behind that I could encounter without having to approve of everything it contained.
And I am glad that, after all these years, I can still recognize the person who wanted to understand the world badly enough to try explaining it.
I would like to keep some of that willingness. I would also like to keep the care, the uncertainty, and the greater understanding the years have brought me.
I do not know exactly how they will live together.
For once, I think I can leave that question open.
Merhaba, ben Prougen.
